Reviews: eyeliner pencil

Makeup

diego dalla palma Eye Pencil, No. 17 Violet

A soft, large pencil from Diego Dalla Palma listed as easy to blend and praised for bright color and all‑day wear. Good small gift for a makeup fan who isn’t sensitive to eye products.

93.6 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Healthy review crowd	+1.1 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	72/100	+0.9 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	66/100	+0.6 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	75/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		93.6

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

HOURGLASS 1.5mm Mechanical Gel Liner

A slim mechanical gel eyeliner with a 1.5mm micro tip that delivers precise, long-wearing lines. Great for tightlining and waterline use, but owners warn it can run out fast and some tubes have breakage issues.

93.8 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Healthy review crowd	+1.3 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	73/100	+0.9 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	60/100	+0.4 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		93.8

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Charlotte Tilbury Rock 'N' Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof Eyeliner with a Precision Smudger Tip - Infused with an Enhanced Kajal Formula for Sultry, Smokey Eyes

A creamy kajal-style pencil with a built-in smudger and strong color payoff. The listing promises long waterproof wear; owners praise glide and blend but some note midday fading.

95.0 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.3 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	82/100	+1.3 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	82/100	+1.3 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		95.0

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Charlotte Tilbury Magic Eyeliner - Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil with Matte & Metallic Finishes - Creamy, Blendable Formula with Up to 16HR Wear - Smudge & Humidity Proof

A dual-ended eyeliner pencil with matte and metallic tips that the listing says delivers up to 16 hours of waterproof, smudge- and humidity-proof wear. Owners report vivid color payoff and long wear; a few say staying power can vary.

94.9 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.4 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	80/100	+1.2 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		94.9

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Estée Lauder Double Wear Long-Lasting Infinite Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil | Includes Built-In Sharpener

A prestige pencil eyeliner with a smudger and built-in sharpener. The listing promises 24-hour waterproof wear; owners praise the color and creaminess but some report breakage and short life.

94.8 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	64/100	+0.6 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		94.8

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Clinique Quickliner For Eyes Intense Eyeliner Pencil | Water Resistant, Smudge Resistant + Safe For Sensitive Eyes | 10 Shades

Clinique's Quickliner For Eyes Intense is an ophthalmologist-tested automatic eyeliner pencil that promises rich color and up to 24-hour, smudge-resistant wear. Owners praise the shade payoff and eye-safety claims but call out product quantity and occasional dryness.

93.8 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Moderate	-1.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	62/100	+0.5 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		93.8

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Lancôme Le Stylo - Waterproof - Long-Lasting Eyeliner

A creamy, waterproof eye pencil with a built-in smudger and several rich shades. Good for makeup fans who want easy application and longwear, with a few smudging and tip issues reported.

94.8 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Minor	-0.5 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		94.8

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Clinique Quickliner For Eyes Eyeliner Pencil | Water Resistant, Smudge Resistant + Safe For Sensitive Eyes | 11 Shades

Clinique Quickliner For Eyes is an automatic, smudge- and transfer-resistant pencil the listing describes as safe for sensitive eyes and contact wearers. Owners praise the silky glide and long wear, while some flag short pencil life or packaging issues.

92.3 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.4★	+88.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Mass-market crowd signal	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Moderate	-1.1 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	88/100	+1.5 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	70/100	+0.8 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		92.3

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge-Proof, Transfer-proof, Long-lasting Color Eye Liners, Hydrating Vitamin E & Jojoba Oil - 0.04 oz

A pigment-packed, creamy pencil famed for long wear and many finishes. Great for bold looks or smoky eyes — but expect sharpening and occasional pencil-core fit issues.

90.9 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.3★	+86.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Mass-market crowd signal	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Minor	-0.5 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	82/100	+1.3 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		90.9

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read