Reviews: eye pencil

Makeup

KIKO Milano Kind by KIKO Lasting Eyeliner &Khol 01, Eye Pencil For The Waterline And Outer Eye

A vegan, ophthalmologically tested eye pencil that promises up to 12 hours of wear. Good for sensitive-eye shoppers — but double-check texture on arrival.

93.5 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.6★	+92.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Small but useful crowd	+0.3 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Significant	-2.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	76/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		93.5

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

diego dalla palma Eye Pencil, No. 17 Violet

A soft, large pencil from Diego Dalla Palma listed as easy to blend and praised for bright color and all‑day wear. Good small gift for a makeup fan who isn’t sensitive to eye products.

93.6 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Healthy review crowd	+1.1 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	72/100	+0.9 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	66/100	+0.6 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	75/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		93.6

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Anastasia Beverly Hills Pro pencil

A sharpenable, creamy matte pencil that owners praise for brow cleanup and long wear. Good as a low-risk stocking stuffer — check shade availability and eye-area suitability before you buy.

96.8 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.6★	+92.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Healthy review crowd	+1.2 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	82/100	+1.3 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		96.8

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Estée Lauder Smoke and Brighten Long-Lasting Waterproof Kajal Eyeliner Pencil Duo, 0.03 Ounce

A compact, dual-ended kajal duo that promises smoky definition plus a brightening shade. Smooth, waterline-safe formula per the listing — but sharpening and longevity opinions are mixed among owners.

87.6 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.2★	+84.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.5 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Moderate	-1.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	76/100	+1.0 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	82/100	+1.3 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	70/100	+0.8 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		87.6

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

butter LONDON WINK Eye Pencil

A glideable, highly pigmented eye pencil that many owners call long-wearing and easy to blend. Good for everyday wear or a colorful accent, with a few texture and packing caveats.

92.3 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.4★	+88.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.5 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Minor	-0.5 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	76/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		92.3

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Clinique Cream Shaper Eyeliner Pencil For Eyes | Water Resistant + Non-Smudging

A creamy, water-resistant pencil that owners call richly pigmented and long-wearing on lids. Good gift for someone who prefers understated, reliable eye color—just watch for packaging hiccups and daily-use cost.

90.4 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.3★	+86.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.6 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Minor	-0.5 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	82/100	+1.3 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	72/100	+0.9 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		90.4

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner | 24-Hour Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil for Long-Lasting, Pigment-Rich Color | Gel Liner for Eye Makeup and Waterline

A waterproof gel pencil that promises 24-hour wear and intense pigment. Owners praise its staying power but warn about sharpening and removal issues—good for anyone who values long-lasting liner.

94.0 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.8 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Moderate	-1.2 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	80/100	+1.2 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		94.0

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

tarte fake awake eye highlight – Brightening Highlighter Pencil for Eyes & Brows, Longwear, Vegan & Cruelty-Free

A compact twist-up brightening pencil that many owners say instantly makes eyes look less tired. Creamy texture and built-in smudger, but some buyers find the shade subtle for waterline use.

91.6 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.4★	+88.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Big owner crowd	+1.9 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Significant	-1.5 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	76/100	+1.0 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	82/100	+1.3 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	72/100	+0.9 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		91.6

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Lancôme Le Crayon Khol - Creamy - Blendable - Long-Wearing Eye Pencil

A luxury-brand kohl pencil that owners praise for creamy application and day-long wear; good as a thoughtful, low-fuss makeup gift if the recipient likes classic eyeliners.

97.5 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.6★	+92.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	80/100	+1.2 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	82/100	+1.3 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	80/100	+1.2 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		97.5

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

jane iredale Eye Pencil Mineral Based with Conditioning Oils and Waxes Natural Pigments & Long Lasting Colors Vegan & Cruellty-Free Eye Makeup

A soft, mineral-based eye pencil the listing describes as vegan and wheat-free. Owners praise the glide and gentle formula but report mixed wear—best as a daily, natural liner rather than a waterproof smokey-eye solution.

93.0 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.4★	+88.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	68/100	+0.7 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		93.0

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

KIKO Milano Unlimited Precision Automatic Eyeliner And Khol Pencil

A user-friendly automatic eye pencil with a built-in applicator and many color options. Owners praise its glide and all-day hold; some report tip breakage or patchy application.

93.2 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.4★	+88.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	No clear signal	+0.0 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	76/100	+1.0 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		93.2

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

KIKO Milano Colour Kajal | Kohl Pencil For The Inner Eye

A soft, creamy kohl pencil that delivers rich pigment and an easy glide; many owners praise comfort and color, but wear on the waterline and sharpening can be mixed.

90.1 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.3★	+86.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Minor	-0.5 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	72/100	+0.9 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	78/100	+1.1 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	66/100	+0.6 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		90.1

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read

Makeup

Lancôme Le Stylo - Waterproof - Long-Lasting Eyeliner

A creamy, waterproof eye pencil with a built-in smudger and several rich shades. Good for makeup fans who want easy application and longwear, with a few smudging and tip issues reported.

94.8 GiftScore

How the GiftScore is calculated

Signal	Reading	Pts
Base rating	4.5★	+90.0 / 100
Review volume confidence	Very large owner crowd	+2.0 (min -2)
Critical owner-feedback signal	Minor	-0.5 (min -2)
GiftScore Build & Materials	78/100	+1.1 (min -3)
GiftScore Safety Signals	80/100	+1.2 (min -4)
GiftScore Long-term Durability	74/100	+1.0 (min -3)
Final GiftScore		94.8

Base rating is an estimated baseline from the owner feedback we have available across Amazon reviews and any credible web sources we reviewed. GiftScore editorial signals (build, safety, longevity) are scored independently of that baseline — they reflect what owner feedback and product specs actually say about the product. Some signals are skipped when they don't fit the product type.

Read